Well, it’s summertime in Texas, which means two things: (1) it’s hot enough to cook eggs on the sidewalk (which is still more sanitary then Denny’s) and (2) it’s time for the State Board of Education to try to dismantle another branch of curriculum. Last year’s struggle was over science. The big debate was whether teachers should be required to spend equal time teaching intelligent design versus evolution. Luckily, for all of us, they decided to stick with evolution as the mainstay. So, what’s on this year’s plate? Social studies.
Now, many of you might be asking, what’s the worst that they can do? After all, much of social studies is based on history and fact. Well, you’d be wrong. In helping to design the curriculum, the state appointed six “experts” to review the current lesson plans and determine what every child would be learning. So, certainly these would include educators, people with curriculum experience, and scholars of history and government, right? Well, yes and no. Certainly, there are qualified historians and professors, but then there is also Peter Marshall, an evangelical minister, and David Barton, a Republican activist. Congressman Smokey Joe Barton (R-eally?) has also weighed in. Their recommendations, which include dropping Thurgood Marshall and Cesar Chavez from curriculum have drawn the ire of many. So, to get the story, I thought that I would sit down for a few words to get to the bottom of this:
Me: Gentlemen, thanks for joining me. I just wanted to find out a bit about why you made the recommendations that you did.
DB: Well, our goal is to rewrite the standards to focus on what the founding fathers intended–a Christian nation based on biblical principles.
PM: Exactly, by interjecting these more recent historical figures, they are ignoring the principle that our great nation was founded upon: that only rich white men get to be famous.
Me: So, you’re telling me that you think that social studies should only focus on famous white men?
DB: Well, not per se, but in practice, yes. I mean, can you name me one significant person who has done anything in this country that wasn’t a white Christian male?
Me: What about Thurgood Marshall?
PM: Don’t even get me started. All he did was win some case and get schools desgregated. If the Founding Fathers had wanted integration, they would have put it into the Constitution. I don’t see it in there anywhere. Plus, as a Supreme Court judge he was a judicial activist, and he made policy, not law. We don’t want our kids growing up with the idea that judges get to make policy.
Me: Sigh. Ok, moving on. What about Cesar Chavez?
DB: I am so sick about hearing about this guy. All he did was give us a salad named after himself. Sure, it’s pretty tasty, and I really like that Southwestern Caesar at Chili’s, but is that enough to get them in the social studies book? I don’t think so. Not to mention the fact that caesar salads are notoriously high in fat. With our kids’ obesity rates rising through the roof, I don’ t think that we should be encouraging unhealthy eating.
Me: Really?! A salad? Ok, fine, what about Anne Hutchinson? She was a colonial leader, an early advocate of women’s rights, and a supporter of religious freedoms. She was also white. Why doesn’t she pass muster?
PM: Are you kidding? It was all of those things that got her kicked out of Massachusetts in the first place. That type of rebellion is unhealthy and I don’t want my kids learning about it. It’s our job to teach social studies, not socialism studies.
Me: Rep. Barton, anything to add?
JB: Well, my complaint is about semantics. All of these text books talk about our “democratic history,” ”democratic” ideals, and “democratic” processes. Since we are really more of a republic, I think that we need to erase the word democratic anywhere that it appears and replace it with “republican.” That way we won’t be teaching our kids the wrong thing.
Me: Well, I’ve had enough of this. Thanks for your time, I’ll let you get back to reading social studies textbooks. Maybe some of it will rub off on you.
As you can see, the right wing is a flappin’ this summer. But, like the high temps, let’s hope that these recommendations fade into something more moderate as the year goes on.
****Note: No actual board members were interviewed, or harmed during the writing of this blog. I can’t say the same for our educational standards.****